Awards: 2005 Institute Honor Award for Regional and Urban Design
Recipient: Goody, Clancy & Associates: Herb Nolan, Ben Carlson, Ron Mallis and Geoffrey Morrison-Logan (left to right)
Project: North Allston Strategic Framework for Planning; Boston
Client: Boston Redevelopment Authority; Boston
Photo: Goody, Clancy & Associates
 

   
 
  AIA Home :: Finding Vision in a Vacant Lot: Architect as Developer :: Side by Side
 
 
 

Become a Member
Renew Your Membership
Careers
Contract Documents
Architect Finder
Find Your Local Component
Find Your Transcript
Soloso

Small Project Practitioners
About Us
Advisory Group
SPP Journal Archive
Related Links
Small Firms
SPP State and Local Contacts
 
Knowledge Communities
AIA Library and Archives
Related Web Sites
Become a Member
AIA eClassroom
 
 
Redefining the Architect's Role: Architects as Agents for Social Change (RUDC)
Coral Gables, FL
March 5 - 7, 2009
 
2009 CBSP Symposium: Vision 2009 Building Commissioning
Washington, DC
March 6, 2009
 
2009 International Conference and Exhibition on Health Facility Planning, Design, and Construction
Phoenix, AZ
March 8 - 11, 2009
 
Environments for Aging .09
Boston , MA
March 29 - 31, 2009
 
Roots and Modernism (COD)
Boston, MA
May 21 - 24, 2009
 
View Calendar
 
 
 
 |  
 

Side by Side

by James E. Collins, AIA
 

Ever walk past new construction in your town or city and say to yourself, "I can do it better?"  I did. 

I'm Jim Collins, Oak Park, Illinois resident and an admitted architectural scavenger, and having said just that to myself many times, I finally decided to do something about it. 

Easy right?  Just ten steps - all the 'how to' books have them.

1. Find a vacant lot that is for sale and affordable.  Oak Park is a suburb on Chicago's western border; the community is built up, but in-fill lots were still scattered around town. 

2. I soon discovered vacant lots that are for sale and affordable are basically the ones everyone else avoided. Let it be a challenge.  Get your creative juices flowing.

I found a long, narrow lot bordered on two sides by alleys in a residential area. That particular side of the street was zoned for limited multi-unit use (a two-unit development only). A contractor's typical solution would be to stack one unit on top of the other.  Instead, I designed a pair of houses on the single, long lot.  This mini-development is not a duplex, not a rowhouse and not two detached single-family dwellings. Instead, it became two single-family homes, joined at their separate two-car garages.

3. Find a contractor.  In this case it wasn't a problem. A small contractor had just finished building my studio/garage next to my Prairie-Style home. We were compatible working together, and willing to take a chance.

4. Find a bank.  Nothing gets built without money. And what lone architect in private practice has any?  So we visited local banks, drawings in hand, plus my portfolio and the hard and soft costs on the proposed project.

5. The local bank is interested.  They liked me; however, banks want collateral. Then came the hard part: convince my wife.  Convince her that putting our house up as collateral is not as risky as it sounds. *Note: this is best done over a pitcher of margaritas.

I wasn't alone.  My contractor/partner was more than likely at an adjoining booth with an even larger pitcher of margaritas trying to convince his wife.

6. Get a permit.  Small-town bureaucracy is the same everywhere. Nothing goes quickly or smoothly.  The building department lost the first set of plans I dropped off. However after two more visits in as many months, they grudgingly gave me a permit.  "A spec house? You're not gonna live there?"

7. Start digging, and immediately attract sidewalk superintendents.  I spent at least ten hours a day at that site. And I thought my wife had it hard during a pregnancy. But this was my baby. And watching what I put on paper come into being, so to speak, was a great experience. 

The exterior is brick, cedar and beige stucco with a definite Prairie-Style trim.  Both homes are reached by the north 'courtyard.'  I didn't take the easy way out: these are not two mirror-image houses; they have two entire different layouts. Each house is over 2,200 square feet (not counting the garages), but the space is used differently in each one.

The front house has three bedrooms, a large living room, and a sun room/den. There are three bedrooms and two full and one-half baths. The rear house has a smaller living room, but gains a bedroom on the first floor.  This house has three full baths and four bedrooms. This house was also designed to be handicapped-accessible.


The homes are slab-on-grade, no basements, in order to cut construction costs.  Both houses have large attics - 12 by 38 feet of usable space that are easily accessible. Already with floors in place, by extending the staircase up a level and providing a skylight an owner can easily expand when finances allow, or space needs dictate, in order to gain another room or two.

Both homes have brick fireplaces that match the brick on the exterior, large well designed kitchens, horizontal wood banding in the living rooms and lots of Prairie-Style casement windows, as well as some inventive uses of angles in the staircase.

In the front unit, the stairway landing pushes a triangle out of the front wall of the house, with two huge tempered glass windows, one on each edge.  This matches another triangle in the upstairs hallway, to form a diamond shape.  Both units have master suites with private baths and walk-in closets. The homes each have a private patio.  The front unit is shielded by shrubbery, while the rear unit has a privacy fence to protect the small back yard from the alley.  The laundry areas are placed upstairs off the hallways and close to the entrances of all three bedrooms. This is, after all, where most of your dirty laundry is generated.


Some touches are immediately apparent, such as marble floors in the baths; others are less so, like insulating the plumbing walls and furnace rooms for sound, and the energy-efficient windows, furnace and wall and ceiling insulation.

I feel that the homes add an interest and brightness to what could have been a mundane corner of Oak Park.

8. Be happy in your work.  Convincing my three teen-age sons that pouring concrete, sweeping up the site, loading and unloading lumber is the basis of good architecture: "Yes Frank Lloyd Wright did it this way. None of his apprentices sat at a drawing board all day."  They will have an understanding of how a building goes up.  "Can't learn it all from a book."

9. Inspections, inspections, repeat, repeat. How can a building department in a small village have so many inspectors?  And why do they have to be told the same thing at least three times?  Finally: an occupancy permit. 


The completed building

10. You're done, now what?  Find a realtor and sell it. Or have your wife get a realtor's license - which mine did. Of course she immediately informed me (over a pitcher of vodka martinis) that building it was easy, but selling it will be hard. Then she found not one, but two buyers, and soon I was turning the keys over to the new owners.

Would I do it again?  In a heartbeat! And I did…four more times.

James E. Collins Architects, in business for over 25 years, is a small architectural/consulting firm specializing in residential, commercial and condominium buildings, both new construction and renovation. Mr. Collins has combined his interest in history & architectural scavenging and restored an 1860 commercial building which was designated a National Historic Site and placed on the National Registry in 2003.